(614) 265-9012

3133 N High St
Columbus, OH 43202 40.0261 -83.0146

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Clintonville

Price:

$

Last updated 7.20.11

Category:

Restaurants

Payment Methods:

Cash

Restaurant Special Features:

Local Favorite, Breakfast, Lunch Spot, Brunch, Cheap Eats

Cuisine:

Traditional American

Smoking Permitted:

No

Reviews & Ratings for Nancy's Home Cooking

4.5 Star Rating: Recommended

32 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a Review
Reviews from:
3.5 Star Rating: Average

08/22/02

Just Like Home

by darmsu at Citysearch

Nancy's is so busy that you don't dare get up from yor seat to get a cup of coffee. Breakfast is "just like Mom used to make" and at a reasonable price. If you don't mind the wait and people drooling on your back while waiting for you to vacate your seat, then Nancy's is the place for you.

  • Pros: price, quantity, taste
  • Cons: crowded
4 Star Rating: Recommended

06/28/11

Part Of my Childhood

by mzjoey28 at Citysearch

I love Nancy's and just thinking about the place makes me smile.. remembering the days when were kid and nothing to worry about sitting side by side with my close friends, and dining with my family...

I still remember those and wanted my kids to have the same memory as I had with Nancy's, they still have the superb food and the warm ambience for family and friends. I hope eventually when my kids are grown ups they'll smile when they reminisce our times here in Nancy's.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

08/13/10

Wonderful catering

by GretchenB at Citysearch

Nancy's catered my wedding last month, & they did an amazing job! The food was so delicious & abundant. Gorgoeus fruit trays (carved birds from apples...I mean all out), pork medallions, vegetarian lasagna, fresh green beans with almond slivers (just to name a few). I heard so many people comment on how tasty the food was. The price was very fair, & Sheila is a sweetheart to work with. She even "threw in as a happy wedding day gift" our party favors...these cute little white boxes containing Jordan almonds.

Thanks Nancy's! You are the best!

-Gretchen & Shawn

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

03/10/10

We missed you Nancy's!!!!!!

by HeaDoH at Citysearch

I LOVE this place, had it once before they closed, I don't live far so I was happy I can walk here (but then they closed) I have been waiting the day once I heard they were opening again =) My fiancee gets a little annoyed with the un organization and the fact that they close at 2p.m. But I think it is worth the delicious food!!!! My favorite is the Beef & Noodles =p Thank You for coming back!!!!!

  • Pros: Best Home Cooking at the Best Price
  • Cons: Crazy Busy, Closes at 2pm =(
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/16/10

YAY!! REOPENING FRIDAY 2/19/2010 YAY!!!!

by Clintonville girl at Citysearch

Thanks everyone for bringing Nancy's back. Clintonville just wouldn' be the same without it!

  • Pros: great comfort food at very reasonable prices
  • Cons: crowded at times
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/03/10

Still being missed

by Organic dude at Citysearch

Update, It has reopened! Food is service are better then ever! Cash only

  • Pros: Best Home cook food in town
  • Cons: Cash Only
4 Star Rating: Recommended

04/10/09

Nancy's will be closing the end of May 2009

by tonyburkhart at Citysearch

It will be missed! Nancy's was a place for a good, hot lunch at a reasonable price. I never got to try the breakfast myself... but the $5 Noodle dish was amazing!

  • Pros: Great price!
  • Cons: It's closing...
4 Star Rating: Recommended

02/12/09

Great Place

Contributor at Citysearch

Food is good and priced right. Park at auto parts

Food is good quality and priced right. Friendly service.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

09/28/08

Great home cooked meal

by mav2121 at Citysearch

The food is great, its as close as your going to get to a home cooked meal in the campus area, which is why its so croweded and always chalked full of college kids (its sort of like a little peice of home). Parking is a bit rough, but then again 90% of the people going there walk from just a few blocks away so they really wont ever need to improve on parking. Itll be most packed on saturday and sunday (post party nights) during the school year so definitly expect a long line on those mornings...other then that you should be fine. The biggest down side to nancys is if your in a group even with one other person...they only bring 1 check a little more then inconvienient for a place getting that much business. If you live south of lane its a bit of a hike, but its worth it. If your south of 15th just drive there is actually PLENTY of parking in the area. You could swing over to blockbuster and park you wont get towed the parking lot is so big...and plenty of parking on East which is a half-a-block from nancys near papa johns.

  • Pros: Good home cooked meal, not to expensive, good service
  • Cons: Depening on the day a long line, no easy parking, Can only have 1 bill to a table,
1 Star Rating: Poor

06/05/08

Slop on a plate not worth the wait.

by KyleRayner1980 at Citysearch

The food isn't bad, but its not worth the trouble. No matter what time you go, expect to wait. Take it from someone who's actually lived behind this place, parking is pretty much nonexistent. Do not park in the lots behind Nancy's, you will be towed, it's for residents ONLY. For some reason, even the owners/employees of Nancy's would repeatedly ignore this, even after several friendly requests not to do so. That to me shows a high level of disrespect to the people of their community. If you're in the mood for driving in circles for 20 minutes trying to park for some slop on a paper plate - have at it.

  • Pros: they have food
  • Cons: nothing special
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

06/14/07

The closest thing to home and only $5

by pinfield61 at Citysearch

I was a little skeptical to try Nancy's, not because I thought the food wasn't good, but because it's always so busy. A bit of advice: try it in the summer when OSU is on break. Trust me, the food will be just as good and you won't have to wait or be hurried out. Monday and Thursday the special is chicken and noodles and the portions are more than you can eat.

  • Pros: Great service, Great food, Cheap
  • Cons: You might have to wait for a seat

Showing 1-10 of 29 reviews

Advertisement

Lists In Columbus

Recent Reviews In Columbus

1 Star Rating: Poor

Texas Road House

1540 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Pasqualone's LaPlaia

5766 Emporium Sq, Columbus, OH

1 Star Rating: Poor

Kihachi Japanese Restaurant

2667 Federated Blvd, Columbus, OH

4 Star Rating: Recommended

Creno's Pizza

5923 Karric Square Dr, Dublin, OH

Advertisement