Little Sicily's Pizza House

05/11/06

Excellent!

by eliza4014 at Citysearch

I didn't think that the Columbus area would have pizza that could touch my favorite pizza (from Chicago) - Well, I was introduced to this pizza from another Chicago native and just LOVE IT!!!

08/01/09

I beg to differ

by gbwcola1 at Citysearch

I read raving reviews and quite frankly decided it must be good. I realize pizza will never be confused for nutritional value but the pizza I ordered was so greasy, I couldn't finish more that one fourth. The pepperoni had puddles of grease. I'm sorry...but I'm going back to Papa Johns.

• Pros: Convenient to my apartment
• Cons: Too much grease

12/19/08

Best in taste

by jpcbus at Citysearch

This pizza is by far my favorite. I've sampled just about every pizza here on the East side and these guys go above and beyond what a good pizza should be. The ingredients are fresh and plentiful. The sausage in particular is one of the best features at Little Sicily's. They use fresh grould sausage on the pizza. CHUNKS of it. Not that little processessed junk you get at most pizza shops/chains. I recently traveled to Chicago and sampled Lou Malnati's and I totally get why the Chicago natives rate this the closest they've found to Chicago style. I think the only thing it's really lacking is being cooked in a pan and it could possibly be better than anything I found in Chicago. If you don't like the mass produced chains that are out there, I suggest you give these guys a try.

• Pros: Different, Fresh, SAUSAGE
• Cons: Getting out of the parking lot.

03/15/08

Our all time Favorite !!!!! We recommend it to everyone. Been regulars for years.

by JASONSMOM at Citysearch

Great family place. They even remember our son loves ice cream and when they ran out they sent someone to get him some. THANKS TIM !!!! Also the best help THANKS ELLEN , KIM and ERICA and all !!!!!

See ya soon

Bob Kathy Jason

• Pros: Best food anything you get
• Cons: Parking is hard sometimes. Go early. Saturdays or Sundays great times

02/29/08

Pastor Z

by PastorZ at Citysearch

I also moved to Columbus from Chicago and Little Sicily's is BY FAR the best pizza I've had in this city. I give them 5 stars.

• Pros: Food is great. Price is reasonable. Service is terrific.
• Cons: Small parking lot - kind of difficult to get in and out.

08/19/02

Perfect pizza everytime!

by chewp123 at Citysearch

I have been going to Little Sicily's for over 10 years. It is the best pizza in Ohio that I have ever tasted. If you like the pizza chains that go easy on the toppings, then this place isn't for you. They really pile the toppings on. The only reason this place isn't in the top 5 is because nobody knows where it is. It's on Old Brice Rd. just off of Brice Rd. Take a right at Circuit City, go about 1 mile and it's on your right. You'll be glad you went. Expect to pay 12.50 for a large 1 topping pizza, and about 18.00-20.00 for a fully loaded pizza that weighs around 5 pounds. Great subs also, I recommend the Famous Sub.

• Pros: value, consistency, package store
• Cons: location, no delivery