Reviews & Ratings for Mitchell's Steak House

Editorial Review by Christy Buena

by Contributor at Citysearch

Romantic restaurant serves prime beef, filet mignon, seafood and a variety of desserts in an elegant atmosphere.

12/19/06

great customer service, great management skills, great steaks and wine selection

by bfoley3251 at Citysearch

I go to Mitchells at least once a month now for years. The General Manager always greats me by my first name when I arrive. He continues to check on me thoughout my dining experence. Service is always great even down to the free valet parking. If you want to have a great dinner experence go to Mitchells.

• Pros: food, parking, customer service
• Cons: slighly higher priced

10/18/06

Great food, atmosphere and staff!

by mdostal at Citysearch

I have had two great meals here along with numerous stops for wine and desserts. Bartenders are always fun and friendly. Food is some of the best I have had in Columbus if you don't mind spending some loot.

11/30/05

One up on Hyde Park

by buckeyedoc76 at Citysearch

I recently tried Mitchell's. I have a difficult time finding a filet that is as good as my secret family recipe, and this restaraunt is no exception. I will say, however, that I was extremely particular and overbearing when it came to cooking the steak. Hyde Park burnt every steak I ordered to a crisp, and I must say Mitchell's very much impressed me. Service was amazing. Side items such as garlic mashed potatoes were whipped and had a funny aftertaste. Overall, Mitchell's was definitely top 3 when compared to other steakhouses in Columbus.

• Pros: service, ambience, overall
• Cons: price, variety, taste

02/25/05

Great!

by lisagoble at Citysearch

When I have the money I love going to this place. Their Filets are the best and their salads are so good! If you ever want to make someone feel special, take them here.

• Pros: Great Food, Great Service, Great Place

08/13/02

Incredible

by JC3553 at Citysearch

The food is unreal and the atmosphear cant be beat. Especially if you are on a date.

• Pros: Excellent Service, Excellent Food, Excellent Atmosphear
• Cons: Expensive