Columbus >Food Stores > Cheryl's Cookies Inc.
17 S. High St., Columbus, OH | Directions 4321539.961697 -83.000811
Neighborhoods: Uptown District
Don't mail order a gift box from Cheryl's! – I ordered a tin of Chery's cookies as a test to be sent to me and my husband for Valentine's Day, thinking if they were good, I'd send some to my granddaughters. Well, I'm sure glad I sent them to us first!
First, the good news: the cookies are very good and fresh.
Now the bad: they arrived pre-packaged in the tin, the cookies individually wrapped, like you see on the counter at a 7-11. No pretty tissue paper in sight. So if you want the item to look pretty and inviting and homemade, not fast-food-like, you'll have to order them sent to you, then you repackage everything with tissue paper to make it look appealing.
I won't be ordering from them again, needless to say. I can get fresh cookies at a dozen bakeries near my home.
Forget to ship!!!!!!! – Stay away from this company!!!!!!I cannot believe when my special gift was never received and I Cheryl and they said that it was never shipped and they were sorry. But what infuriated me was they offered to send out the same gift pack several days late or that I could pay them more money to order a different box that would show up several days late as well. What should have happened is that good customer service would require fedexing my package overnight with a letter of apology. So, I ended up really frustrated and my son never received his box of cookies to commemorate the holiday.
YUMMY COOKIES...THE BEST!! – I sent my Grandson, 14 yrs old, the Birthday Cookie Tin and he was so excited. Needless to say he enjoyed the cookies because he did not share any with his Mom...LOL. I sent my Mother and my Daughter the Mother's Day special with a combination of all the cookies and I received a call from each one saying how much they loved the cookies! They both said "They are the best!!!" In fact, my daughter has decided now to use Cheryl's for her cookie needs. If you really want to eat an "old school" type of cookie that you can't find anymore, try Cheryl's. Just once and believe me you are hooked....line and sinker too!!! I am now on automatic delivery for this year and I am so excited about it! Free shipping and I will have Cheryl's cookies for all my entertaining needs....it's great! Cheryl, thanks so much for taking the time to produce an absolutely wonderful product. You have really taken the time to do it right and each cookie taste like you made it with all the love of your grandma! Congrats on a great product!
A hometown favorite: delicious cookies, brownies and cakes that make great gifts.
– Smart Cookie
Cheryl Krueger-Horn started Cheryl's cookies in 1981 with her grandmother's cookie recipe and a single store here in Columbus. Today, it's a multi-million dollar company that does business all over the country through its catalogues, web site and corporate clients.
Good Baked Goods
Cheryl's is known for big, soft, fresh cookies in individual packages. Cookies come in all the classic flavors: chocolate chips, oatmeal raisin, sugar, white chocolate chip, butterscotch, peanut butter and spice. They also sell decadent brownies and cakes. You can even buy raw cookie dough and bake them yourself.
If your sweetie has a sweet tooth, forget flowers and buy a cookie bouquet. For $39.99 you get a dozen cookies wrapped in red cellophane and mixed with silk flowers and greenery. It looks like a dozen roses but tastes much better.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Do you have a review of Cheryl's Cookies Inc. on your blog? If you include the Citysearch image link (shown below) in your post, we'll automatically link to your review from the business profile page. Here's how our Linkback system works:
The Linkback system is free and automatic. It's really that easy.
To link to our business profile page, copy the html below to your web page.