Bexley Pizza Plus

Doesn't Recommend

dlgjew

Joined 4 years ago

All hype. I was surprised at the poor service and over priced pizza which was not that good at all.

Too doughy, under cooked. I had to bring it home and finish baking it.

Doesn't Recommend

gigant0r

Joined 4 years ago

not a fan. I don't get the hype for this pizza. it's overpriced and tastes nothing special at all. If in Bexley, go for Anthony's or Rubinos instead.

Recommends

lrock4

Joined 6 years ago

The New Plus Rocks!. You've gotta check out the "new plus". Same great zas, new location with dine-In, beer and wine. Ordered two pizzas --- Chicken Florentine & Primavera Plus---outstanding crust, fresh veggies and great service!

Recommends

ejl

Joined 9 years ago

sad about columbus pizza. I tried Bexley Pizza Plus for the 1st time yesterday and was very disappointed, especially after reading all the good reviews. The crust was described as thick, chewy, and homeade, but what i had was thin, flavorless, and clearly NOT homeade. It tasted like any other frozen pizza crust you get everywhere else in this city devoid of anything even beginning to resemble good pizza. I also think it is way too expensive for what it is. I would not recommend.

Recommends

mcmillb1

Joined 10 years ago

Best Vegetarian Pizza. BPP has the BEST veggie pizza in Columbus - The Farmer's Market. A combination of spinach, broccoli, roma tomatoes and feta cheese with the red sauce is PERFECT! Even meat eaters will love it!

Recommends

Contributor

Joined 10 years ago

The least pretentious gourmet pizza you'll ever have.. The Scene
Inside this unassuming carryout on East Main Street you'll find some of the best pizza in Columbus. Like most pizza places, it's got a counter, pizza ovens and a cooler full of soda. But it's also got a lengthy menu of gourmet toppings. Family owned and operated for over 20 years, the shop has become a destination for people from around the city.


The Food
A fresh handmade crust is part of what makes this pizza so good. Thick and chewy, it's topped with tangy sauce and real cheese. Choose from combinations such as the chicken cacciatora, with chicken breast, roma tomatoes, green peppers, onions and fresh garlic. Another favorite is the Greek pizza, with feta cheese, sundried tomatoes, artichoke hearts and black olives. At dinnertime, the pizza only comes in two sizes--12" or 16", but you can get an 8" pie at lunchtime only. They also have subs, salads and garlic bread.

Recommends

assaultpredator

Joined 11 years ago

Excellent. Bexley Pizza Plus has excellent pizza, great service, is fast, efficient, and has good prices. The only downfall of this pizza place is that it is not a restaraunt, and does not deliver. However, Pizza Plus is very much recommended to anyone in the Columbus area, and extremely recommended to anyone near Bexley.

Recommends

nikreel

Joined 11 years ago

Simply The Best!. Always great, dependable and just the way you want it done.

Recommends

chrispyshot

Joined 11 years ago

awesome. Great pizza!! I had it years ago,, then they opened up a location in Gahanna right around the corner from me. I eat Pizza Plus weekly, and it's always consistent. Two weeks ago I had the Mexican pizza, superb!!!! Keep up the good work guys!!!

Recommends

osugirl

Joined 11 years ago

Good... but not the best!. I have had this pizza, and I really don't see what the rave is. The dough was thick. More like bread. I guess if you like that, then this is your place. I'd rather enjoy the toppings!