Great pie, Excellent service.
We've been to Josiah's a few times for lunch. The food has been consistently good and the service excellent. When I dined with a broken (dominant) hand in a cast, they went out of their way to make managing the food "wrong-handed" easy for me. They've also accomdated special requests/substitutions with a smile. They make fresh pies for desert and are more than happy to inform you what they have that day before you order lunch so you can plan accordingly to save room! We've never had a bad piece of pie at Josiah's. The restaurant is very small so don't expect to come with a group of 8 or 10 or more and be accomodated easily. There is outside, umbrella table seating on the sidewalk along Broadway. We've never been there when outside seating was in operation but it seems like a neat option for real people watcher types.