Catalfino's Pizza & Pub

Recommends

sonhar17

Joined 2 years ago

Great Pizza. The pizza is amazing!!!

The garlic bread is pretty amazing too!!!

The pasta dishes.....not so amazing (cold and tateless).

Great location - although not easy to get to. Nicing seating outside!

The owner, Jim Catalfino, was out mingling with the guests and you could really tell that he has a lot of repeat customers.

I will definately go back for the pizza!!!!!!

Doesn't Recommend

chris1961

Joined 8 years ago

Terrible pie. They have moved from Refugee Rd. to 256 & 204. The new place is nice...large bar, lots of TVs and outdoor seating. However, the love stops there. My wife and I ordered a small pep, mush, yellow pepper, green pepper, and green pepper, an Italian sub, and fried mushrooms. service was slow...two other tables got their food before us, but came in after us. The mushrooms arrived first, but were still frozen in the middle...had to send them back. Our pizza and sub showed up, and the sub was all bread. Just a small thin single layer of meat and cheese, drenched in Italian dressing. The pizza was so greasy, we could literally pour it from the pan. It pooled on our plates, and mad the crust soggy. Id hate to see a pies with more meats or whatnot...Im guessing it would even be worse. Sorry, not worth the visit...I wont be going back.

Recommends

rsrswildheart

Joined 4 years ago

GOURMET PIZZA IS AVERAGE. WE HAVE TRIED THIS PLACE SEVERAL TIMES AND HAVE FOUND THE PIZZA TO BE AVERAGE, THE SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP IS HORRIBLE AND THE SUBS ARE ALL BREAD. WE WERE NOT IMPRESSED AT ALL. THE SERVICE WAS HORRIBLE AS WELL. WE WILL NOT BE BACK. BETTER PIZZA TO BE FOUND AT GRAPEVINE OR RUBINO'S IN BEXLEY.

Recommends

sgrinstead

Joined 6 years ago

Best pizza on the east side of Columbus. The best pizza that I have had in Columbus in 5 years. The crust tasted fresh, was crispy and still supported all of the toppings.

If you manage to fight the traffice on Gender road to Refugee then you will not be disappointed. I ate at the bar for my first visit and the staff made me feel like a regular.